| July |
| W | Sat 2/7/2011 | Frdly | Eastfield |  | 0-4 |  | Scarborough Athletic Chris Hewitt 9 Ant Lynam 35, 59 Luke Foster 63 | Att: 310 HT: 0-2 |
| (at Yorkshire Coast College) |
| W | Tue 5/7/2011 | Frdly | Hucknall Town |  | 0-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Chris Hewitt 74 | Att: 124 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Sat 9/7/2011 | Frdly | Eccleshill United Andy Howland 82 |  | 1-3 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 25 Matt Draper 29 James Webb 88 | Att: 135 HT: 0-2 |
| L | Tue 12/7/2011 | Frdly | Frickley Athletic Danny Walsh 9 Ben Leonard 62 |  | 2-0 |  | Scarborough Athletic | Att: 177 HT: 1-0 |
| W | Sat 16/7/2011 | Frdly | St Ives Town Connor Washington 23 |  | 1-2 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 54 Ant Lynam 68 | Att: 112 HT: 1-0 |
| W | Sun 17/7/2011 | Frdly | Dereham Town Kyle Downes 16 Andrew Cusack 78pen |  | 2-3 |  | Scarborough Athletic Matt Draper 9 Ryan Blott 26pen Chris Hewitt 55 | Att: 103 HT: 1-2 |
| W | Tue 19/7/2011 | Frdly | Goole AFC |  | 0-2 |  | Scarborough Athletic | |
| W | Sat 23/7/2011 | Frdly | Shirebrook Town Peter Stubley 4 |  | 1-4 |  | Scarborough Athletic Tony Hackworth 34 Joe Naylor 52 Curtis Bernard 70 Ant Lynam 78 | Att: 150 HT: 1-1 |
| D | Tue 26/7/2011 | Frdly | Scarborough Athletic Bill Law 8 |  | 1-1 |  | Westella & Willerby John Slater 80 | Att: 142 HT: 1-0 |
| L | Sat 30/7/2011 | Frdly | Scarborough Athletic Joe Naylor 49 |  | 1-2 |  | Ossett Town Dec Normanchild 12 Kevin Sanasy 30 | Att: 243 HT: 0-2 |
| August |
| W | Tue 2/8/2011 | Frdly | Scarborough Athletic Tony Hackworth 21pen Curtis Bernard 35, 52 Mark Griffin 75 |  | 4-2 |  | Sculcoates Amateurs James Rudd 13 Richard Sidwell 60 | Att: 78 HT: 2-1 |
| (at Bishop Burton College) |
| W | Sat 6/8/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Scott Phillips 36 Tony Hackworth 74, 79 Joel Hartley 90 |  | 4-2 |  | Parkgate Nathan Swindells 13, 39 | Att: 515 HT: 1-2 |
| W | Sat 13/8/2011 | NCELP | Tadcaster Albion |  | 0-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Tony Hackworth 4 | Att: 324 HT: 0-1 |
| L | Wed 17/8/2011 | LC2 | Bottesford Town Lee Bognar 54, 60 |  | 2-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Joe Naylor 52 | Att: 125 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Sat 20/8/2011 | FACEP | Scarborough Athletic Tony Hackworth 4 Ryan Blott 25 Curtis Bernard 89 Ant Lynam 90 |  | 4-0 |  | Hallam | Att: 452 HT: 2-0 |
| L | Tue 23/8/2011 | NCELP | Brighouse Town Jacob Lever 6 Andrew Hawker 41 |  | 2-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 90 | Att: 210 HT: 2-0 |
| L | Mon 29/8/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 60 |  | 1-3 |  | Long Eaton United Shaun Rickford 32, 81, 90 | Att: 447 HT: 0-1 |
| September |
| D | Sat 3/9/2011 | FACP | Scarborough Athletic Patrick Miller 34 Joe Naylor 40 |  | 2-2 |  | Barton Town Old Boys Simon Spencer 13 Rob Northen 86pen | Att: 498 HT: 2-1 |
| (Replay: Tuesday 6th September, 7.45pm) |
| W | Tue 6/9/2011 | FACPR | Barton Town Old Boys |  | 0-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ant Lynam 40 | Att: 246 HT: 0-1 |
| W | Sat 10/9/2011 | NCELP | Lincoln Moorlands Railway |  | 0-4 |  | Scarborough Athletic Joe Naylor 5 Curtis Bernard 65, 74 Ant Lynam 73 | Att: 172 HT: 0-1 |
| L | Sat 17/9/2011 | FAC1Q | Tadcaster Albion Daniel Gray 15, 64 Carl Stewart 86 |  | 3-0 |  | Scarborough Athletic | Att: 472 HT: 1-0 |
| W | Sat 24/9/2011 | FAV2Q | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 7 Bill Law 17 Curtis Bernard 19 Gary Hepples 22 Ant Lynam 90 |  | 5-1 |  | Worsbrough Bridge Athletic Matthew Roberts 4 | Att: 408 HT: 4-1 |
| October |
| W | Sat 1/10/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Joe Naylor 28 Curtis Bernard 69 Gary Hepples 72 |  | 3-2 |  | Winterton Rangers Danny Frost 39, 90 | Att: 379 HT: 1-1 |
| W | Tue 4/10/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town |  | 0-4 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 20, 81 Curtis Bernard 67 Bill Law 90 | Att: 564 HT: 0-1 |
| W | Sat 8/10/2011 | NCELP | Maltby Main |  | 0-6 |  | Scarborough Athletic Curtis Bernard 2, 85 Tony Hackworth 32 Joe Naylor 39 Ryan Blott 60pen Scott Phillips 67 | Att: 215 HT: 0-3 |
| W | Sat 15/10/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Curtis Bernard 32, 39 |  | 2-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 426 HT: 2-0 |
| L | Sat 22/10/2011 | FAV1 | Parkgate Keir Hannity 51 Ashley Worsfold 90 |  | 2-0 |  | Scarborough Athletic | Att: 295 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Sat 29/10/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Tony Hackworth 80 Patrick Miller 90 |  | 2-1 |  | Hall Road Rangers James McGarry 42 | Att: 493 HT: 0-1 |
| November |
| W | Sat 5/11/2011 | NCELP | Thackley |  | 0-5 |  | Scarborough Athletic Curtis Bernard 1 Joe Naylor 11, 45 Ryan Blott 13, 83 | Att: 208 HT: 0-4 |
| D | Tue 8/11/2011 | NCELP | Parkgate Nathan Swindells 1 |  | 1-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Patrick Miller 7 | Att: 252 HT: 1-1 |
| D | Sat 12/11/2011 | NCELP | Retford United Carl Haslam 48 |  | 1-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Joe Naylor 90 | Att: 383 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Tue 15/11/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Joe Naylor 45 |  | 1-2 |  | Staveley Miners Welfare Christopher Coy 3 Joe Thornton 90 | Att: 394 HT: 1-1 |
| W | Sat 19/11/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Craig Heard 4 Fran Pariente 43 |  | 2-5 |  | Scarborough Athletic Curtis Bernard 29, 54, 87 Dean Windass 75 Bill Law 84 | Att: 326 HT: 2-1 |
| L | Tue 22/11/2011 | NRSC2 | Scarborough Athletic Bill Law 42 |  | 1-5 |  | Guisborough Town Liam McPhilips 17 Michael Roberts 21 Chris I'Anson 28, 34 David Onions 60 | Att: 159 HT: 1-4 |
| W | Sat 26/11/2011 | NCELP | Armthorpe Welfare Chris Davies 75pen |  | 1-4 |  | Scarborough Athletic Curtis Bernard 15, 64, 79 Matt Draper 46 | Att: 203 HT: 0-1 |
| W | Tue 29/11/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 63 James Ghaichem 87 |  | 2-1 |  | Tadcaster Albion Terry Taylor 48 | Att: 474 HT: 0-0 |
| December |
| D | Sat 3/12/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Patrick Miller 72 Matt Draper 84 Ryan Blott 89 |  | 3-3 |  | Liversedge Nathan Cartman 20 Jamie Wasley 25 Alex Hallam 70 | Att: 465 HT: 0-2 |
| L | Sat 10/12/2011 | NCELP | Barton Town Old Boys Scott Phillips 43 Tom Lee 60 |  | 2-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Joe Naylor 40 | Att: 254 HT: 1-1 |
| L | Sat 17/12/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 37, 54 Bill Law 48 |  | 3-4 |  | Barton Town Old Boys Tom Lee 18, 64 Martin Cooper 77 Richard Medcalf 90 | Att: 402 HT: 1-1 |
| L | Mon 26/12/2011 | NCELP | Bridlington Town Craig Hogg 25, 55 Ashley Allanson 40 |  | 3-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Tony Hackworth 85 | Att: 802 HT: 2-0 |
| January |
| W | Sat 7/1/2012 | NCELP | Long Eaton United |  | 0-5 |  | Scarborough Athletic Tony Hackworth 7 Adam Lee 45, 46 Ryan Blott 77, 79 | Att: 169 HT: 0-2 |
| D | Tue 10/1/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 18 Adam Lee 19 |  | 2-2 |  | Nostell Miners Welfare Brad Thompson 11 Graham Marchant 13 | Att: 312 HT: 2-2 |
| W | Sat 14/1/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 4, 74pen Adam Lee 35 |  | 3-1 |  | Pickering Town David Hartas 6 | Att: 508 HT: 2-1 |
| L | Sat 21/1/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Tony Hackworth 5 |  | 1-2 |  | Bridlington Town Billy Logan 48, 83 | Att: 748 HT: 1-0 |
| W | Sat 28/1/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 43, 58 Adam Lee 57 |  | 3-1 |  | Lincoln Moorlands Railway Luke Forbes 86 | Att: 347 HT: 1-0 |
| February |
| L | Sat 18/2/2012 | NCELP | Winterton Rangers James O'Neill 64pen Kyle Hadley 87 |  | 2-0 |  | Scarborough Athletic | Att: 208 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Sat 25/2/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Adam Lee 67 Tony Hackworth 73 Ryan Blott 79 |  | 3-0 |  | Maltby Main | Att: 398 HT: 0-0 |
| March |
| W | Sat 3/3/2012 | NCELP | Nostell Miners Welfare |  | 0-1 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 61pen | Att: 196 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Sat 10/3/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Curtis Bernard 75 |  | 1-2 |  | Arnold Town Luke Smithson 2 Martin Carruthers 49 | Att: 367 HT: 0-1 |
| W | Sat 17/3/2012 | NCELP | Hall Road Rangers Neil Towler 22, 50 Mark Griffin 43 |  | 3-4 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 13, 53, 63 Patrick Miller 20 | Att: 164 HT: 2-2 |
| W | Tue 20/3/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic James Ghaichem 65 Ryan Blott 85 |  | 2-0 |  | Brighouse Town | Att: 254 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Sat 24/3/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 36 Bill Law 56 |  | 2-0 |  | Thackley | Att: 327 HT: 1-0 |
| D | Sat 31/3/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Bill Law 5 James Ghaichem 65 |  | 2-2 |  | Retford United Warren Hatfield 18, 27 | Att: 389 HT: 1-2 |
| April |
| L | Mon 9/4/2012 | NCELP | Arnold Town Chris Freestone 2 Josh Schofield 36, 45 |  | 3-0 |  | Scarborough Athletic | Att: 178 HT: 3-0 |
| W | Sat 14/4/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 9, 24, 50, 54, 56 Curtis Bernard 83 |  | 6-0 |  | Armthorpe Welfare | Att: 320 HT: 2-0 |
| W | Sat 21/4/2012 | NCELP | Liversedge Patrick McGuire 5 Cory Larkin 67pen |  | 2-3 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 45, 90 Wilf Dinsdale 74 | Att: 210 HT: 1-1 |
| May |
| W | Wed 2/5/2012 | NCELP | Staveley Miners Welfare |  | 0-3 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 10, 42 Tony Hackworth 65 | Att: 158 HT: 0-2 |