| July |
| L | Wed 6/7/2011 | Frdly | Selby Town Ashley Lattimore 32 |  | 1-3 |  | Hessle Rangers Mike Jones 10 Des O'Malley 38 Lee Gardner 77 | Att: 48 HT: 1-2 |
| D | Wed 13/7/2011 | Frdly | Selby Town Andy Ricketts 88 |  | 1-1 |  | Grimsby Borough Josh Fuller 75 | HT: 0-0 |
| L | Tue 19/7/2011 | Frdly | Selby Town |  | 0-1 |  | Grimsby Town XI Jack Bradbury 37 | Att: 58 HT: 0-1 |
| W | Sat 23/7/2011 | Frdly | Selby Town Ian Beckram 38 Johnathan Wileman 62 |  | 2-1 |  | Whitkirk Wanderers Dean Dewing 29 | Att: 36 HT: 1-1 |
| L | Thu 28/7/2011 | Frdly | Appleby Frodingham Steve McCarron 16, 53 Tom Finnigan 35, 36, 52 |  | 5-1 |  | Selby Town Gary Collier 50 | HT: 3-0 |
| L | Sat 30/7/2011 | Frdly | Bedlington Terriers Anthony Shandran 10, 69, 84 Tommy English 34 Richard Flynn 46 Stephen Bowie 81pen |  | 6-1 |  | Selby Town Jamie Sherlock 70 | Att: 96 HT: 2-0 |
| August |
| L | Tue 2/8/2011 | Frdly | Selby Town Ashley Lattimore 10 |  | 1-2 |  | Goole AFC Vill Powell 35 Derry Robson 60 | Att: 126 HT: 1-1 |
| L | Sat 6/8/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Mike Thompson 42 |  | 1-4 |  | Pickering Town Joel Ramm 60 David Watson 70, 90 Mark Triffitt 89 | Att: 138 HT: 1-0 |
| L | Sat 13/8/2011 | NCELP | Bridlington Town Ashley Allanson 4 Josh Greening 30, 52, 59 Craig Hogg 44, 53 Tom Fleming 67 |  | 7-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 162 HT: 3-0 |
| D | Wed 17/8/2011 | LC2 | Lincoln Moorlands Railway |  | 0-0 (aet) |  | Selby Town | Att: 53 |
| (Selby Town win 7-6 on penalties) |
| L | Sat 20/8/2011 | FACEP | Selby Town Craig Aspinall 64 |  | 1-4 |  | Liversedge David Boardman 29 Alex Hallam 39pen, 44 Chris Hawney 62 | Att: 107 HT: 0-3 |
| D | Wed 24/8/2011 | NCELP | Winterton Rangers Liam Wilkin 71 |  | 1-1 |  | Selby Town Ashley Lattimore 90 | Att: 77 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Sat 27/8/2011 | NCELP | Staveley Miners Welfare Christopher Coy 43 Joe Thornton 80 Jordan Eagers 90 |  | 3-1 |  | Selby Town Craig Aspinall 1 | Att: 118 HT: 1-1 |
| L | Mon 29/8/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-1 |  | Lincoln Moorlands Railway Nathan Adams 80 | Att: 87 HT: 0-0 |
| September |
| L | Sat 3/9/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Gary Collier 84 |  | 1-2 |  | Brighouse Town Steve Hollingworth 40 Shane Hamilton 59 | Att: 88 HT: 0-1 |
| L | Tue 6/9/2011 | NCELP | Thackley Brice Tiani 2 Nicky Matthews 12, 20 Dean Walters 27, 44 |  | 5-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 65 HT: 5-0 |
| L | Sat 10/9/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Matt Hanton 30 |  | 1-2 |  | Long Eaton United Matt Weightman 47 Elliot King 84 | Att: 80 HT: 1-0 |
| D | Sat 17/9/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Gary Collier 1 Craig Aspinall 56 |  | 2-2 |  | Maltby Main Greg Mason 32 Rob Branagan 47 | Att: 55 HT: 1-1 |
| W | Sat 24/9/2011 | FAV2Q | Selby Town Craig Heard 54, 63 |  | 2-1 |  | Winterton Rangers Liam Wilkin 3 | Att: 90 HT: 0-1 |
| October |
| W | Sat 1/10/2011 | NCELP | Arnold Town Mitchell Slawson 74 Liam Garner 79, 83 |  | 3-4 |  | Selby Town Craig Heard 15, 23, 86 Martin Carruthers 49og | Att: 90 HT: 0-2 |
| L | Sat 8/10/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-1 |  | Hall Road Rangers Grant Normington 49pen | Att: 70 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Sat 15/10/2011 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Curtis Bernard 32, 39 |  | 2-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 426 HT: 2-0 |
| L | Sat 22/10/2011 | FAV1 | Askern Villa Ashley Towler 27 Tom McLaughlin 35, 60 |  | 3-1 |  | Selby Town Craig Aspinall 45 | Att: 89 HT: 2-1 |
| L | Sat 29/10/2011 | NCELP | Nostell Miners Welfare James Eyles 18 Emmanuel Siaw 35, 43 |  | 3-1 |  | Selby Town Craig Aspinall 60 | Att: 60 HT: 3-0 |
| L | Mon 31/10/2011 | WRCC1 | Albion Sports Aron Heywood 33, 52, 64 Lukas Wiacok 42og Danny Brown 70 |  | 6-3 |  | Selby Town Tom Hyde 40, 76 Craig Aspinall 63 | Att: 41 HT: 2-1 |
| November |
| W | Sat 5/11/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Tom Hyde 15 Nick Black 25 Craig Heard 80 |  | 3-1 |  | Armthorpe Welfare Louis Blackwell 41og | Att: 80 HT: 2-1 |
| L | Sat 12/11/2011 | NCELP | Liversedge Nathan Cartman 12, 84 David Boardman 60 Joe Jagger 89 |  | 4-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 108 HT: 1-0 |
| D | Tue 15/11/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Craig Heard 5, 76 |  | 2-2 |  | Bridlington Town Ashley Allanson 25 Danny Brunton 55 | Att: 110 HT: 1-1 |
| L | Sat 19/11/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Craig Heard 4 Fran Pariente 43 |  | 2-5 |  | Scarborough Athletic Curtis Bernard 29, 54, 87 Dean Windass 75 Bill Law 84 | Att: 326 HT: 2-1 |
| L | Sat 26/11/2011 | NCELP | Parkgate Christopher Wood 27 Nathan Swindells 31 Gareth Clayton 37 Ashley Worsfold 76 |  | 4-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 88 HT: 3-0 |
| December |
| L | Sat 3/12/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-1 |  | Tadcaster Albion Jamie Hopcutt 18 | Att: 90 HT: 0-1 |
| L | Tue 6/12/2011 | Frdly | Selby Town |  | 2-6 |  | Bradford Park Avenue | Att: 32 |
| L | Sat 10/12/2011 | NCELP | Long Eaton United Matt Weightman 41 Michael Armstrong 68 |  | 2-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 68 HT: 1-0 |
| L | Tue 13/12/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-1 |  | Barton Town Old Boys Ashley Dexter 21 | Att: 70 HT: 0-1 |
| L | Mon 26/12/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town Michael McNaughton 10 Jonathan Brown 23 Tom Reid 43 |  | 3-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 180 HT: 3-0 |
| January |
| L | Mon 2/1/2012 | NCELP | Selby Town Matthew Friend 40 |  | 1-2 |  | Liversedge David Boardman 20 Daniel Cooper 90 | Att: 130 HT: 1-1 |
| L | Sat 7/1/2012 | NCELP | Lincoln Moorlands Railway Josh Nichol 14 Danny Hargreaves 65 Ben Garrick 82 |  | 3-1 |  | Selby Town Craig Aspinall 61 | Att: 73 HT: 1-0 |
| L | Sat 14/1/2012 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-2 |  | Staveley Miners Welfare Ryan Damms 40pen Simon Barraclough 55 | Att: 82 HT: 0-1 |
| L | Sat 21/1/2012 | NCELP | Brighouse Town Unknown 14og Anthony Haigh 16, 28 Nick Jagger 52 Tom Matthews 58 James Sutcliffe 81pen |  | 6-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 60 HT: 3-0 |
| W | Sat 28/1/2012 | NCELP | Selby Town Craig Aspinall 81pen Ben Slater 90 |  | 2-1 |  | Winterton Rangers Graeme Severn 36 | Att: 68 HT: 0-1 |
| February |
| L | Sat 18/2/2012 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-4 |  | Arnold Town Tyrone Burton 10 Ryan Whitehurst 45, 55 Liam Garner 87 | Att: 80 HT: 0-2 |
| L | Sat 25/2/2012 | NCELP | Hall Road Rangers Steve Gawthorpe 31 Paul Wilson 44 Steve Graham 49 |  | 3-1 |  | Selby Town Roy Fogarty 24 | Att: 30 HT: 2-1 |
| March |
| L | Sat 3/3/2012 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-4 |  | Thackley Kris Hargreaves 34 Mark Bett 41, 50 Delroy White 88 | Att: 67 HT: 0-2 |
| L | Tue 6/3/2012 | NCELP | Barton Town Old Boys Declan Marshall 53 Matthew Plant 66 |  | 2-1 |  | Selby Town Fran Pariente 78 | Att: 70 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Sat 10/3/2012 | NCELP | Retford United Chris Baugh 30 Adam Scott 45, 62 Warren Hatfield 83 |  | 4-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 159 HT: 2-0 |
| L | Tue 13/3/2012 | LC3 | Nostell Miners Welfare Brad Thompson 9, 83 Liam Coughlan 28pen James Eyles 31 |  | 4-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 44 HT: 3-0 |
| L | Sat 17/3/2012 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-4 |  | Nostell Miners Welfare Liam Coughlan 38 James Eyles 44, 77 Tom Hope 83 | Att: 60 HT: 0-2 |
| L | Sat 24/3/2012 | NCELP | Armthorpe Welfare Craig Wilkinson 28 Tom Hyde 52 Craig Morley 56 Henry Sibenge 65 |  | 4-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 68 HT: 1-0 |
| April |
| L | Sat 7/4/2012 | NCELP | Selby Town Abbas Sadeghian 49 |  | 1-2 |  | Retford United Karl Slack 12 Adam Colton 64 | Att: 110 HT: 0-1 |
| L | Sat 14/4/2012 | NCELP | Selby Town |  | 0-5 |  | Parkgate Brian Cusworth 2 Nathan Swindells 11, 47, 86, 90 | Att: 52 HT: 0-2 |
| L | Sat 21/4/2012 | NCELP | Tadcaster Albion Nick Thompson 29, 63 Brenton Leister 65pen |  | 3-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 79 HT: 1-0 |
| L | Sat 28/4/2012 | NCELP | Maltby Main Rob Branagan 9 Paul Lavender 90 |  | 2-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 62 HT: 1-0 |