| July |
| L | Tue 19/7/2011 | Frdly | Pickering Town |  | 0-3 |  | Whitby Town | |
| L | Sat 23/7/2011 | Frdly | Marske United Unknown 88pen |  | 1-0 |  | Pickering Town | HT: 0-0 |
| W | Tue 26/7/2011 | Frdly | Pickering Town |  | 8-1 |  | Scarborough Town | |
| W | Fri 29/7/2011 | Frdly | Pickering Town |  | 5-3 |  | Kirkbymoorside | |
| August |
| W | Sat 6/8/2011 | NCELP | Selby Town Mike Thompson 42 |  | 1-4 |  | Pickering Town Joel Ramm 60 David Watson 70, 90 Mark Triffitt 89 | Att: 138 HT: 1-0 |
| L | Sat 13/8/2011 | NCELP | Arnold Town Josh Schofield 8 Martin Carruthers 52 Luke Smithson 56 |  | 3-1 |  | Pickering Town Joel Ramm 24 | Att: 101 HT: 1-1 |
| W | Sun 21/8/2011 | FACEP | Pickering Town Jonathan Andrew 42 Kingsley Wetherald 63 |  | 2-0 |  | Dinnington Town | Att: 157 HT: 1-0 |
| L | Mon 29/8/2011 | NCELP | Hall Road Rangers Neil Towler 64, 82 Michael Bettney 81 |  | 3-0 |  | Pickering Town | Att: 72 HT: 0-0 |
| September |
| D | Sat 3/9/2011 | FACP | Liversedge Damian Hopkins 83 Joe Jagger 85 |  | 2-2 |  | Pickering Town Steve Baxter 33 Kingsley Wetherald 72 | Att: 130 HT: 0-1 |
| (Replay: Tuesday 6th September, 7.45pm) |
| D | Tue 6/9/2011 | FACPR | Pickering Town David Watson 13 Tom Adams 23pen Steve Baxter 42 |  | 3-3 (aet) |  | Liversedge Brook Newton 33 James Hurtley 58, 72 | Att: 137 HT: 3-1 90: 3-3 |
| (Pickering Town win 5-4 on penalties) |
| L | Sat 10/9/2011 | NCELP | Nostell Miners Welfare James Eyles 9, 16, 29, 80 Ernest Boafo 43 Franck Zalo 44 Matthew Denton 61 |  | 7-3 |  | Pickering Town Luke Woodall 45 Steve Baxter 49 Kingsley Wetherald 73pen | Att: 62 HT: 5-1 |
| L | Tue 13/9/2011 | PC1 | Pickering Town Kingsley Wetherald 67 Lewis Taylor 90 |  | 2-3 |  | Bridlington Town Craig Hogg 31 Josh Greening 37, 40 | Att: 125 HT: 0-3 |
| D | Sat 17/9/2011 | FAC1Q | Pickering Town Stuart Rice 32 Kingsley Wetherald 41 |  | 2-2 |  | Staveley Miners Welfare Tom Jones 48 Simon Barraclough 76 | Att: 118 HT: 2-0 |
| (Replay: Wednesday 21st September, 7:45pm) |
| L | Wed 21/9/2011 | FAC1QR | Staveley Miners Welfare Gavin Smith 23 Ryan Damms 62pen Andrew Fox 75 Adam Houghton 85 |  | 4-0 |  | Pickering Town | Att: 124 HT: 1-0 |
| L | Sat 24/9/2011 | FAV2Q | Pickering Town Joel Ramm 62 |  | 1-2 |  | Thackley Dean Walters 3 Nicky Matthews 22 | Att: 102 HT: 0-2 |
| D | Tue 27/9/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town Mark Triffitt 53 Steve Baxter 56 |  | 2-2 |  | Liversedge James Hurtley 29 Darryl Leach 70 | Att: 122 HT: 0-1 |
| October |
| L | Sat 1/10/2011 | NCELP | Barton Town Old Boys Ashley Dexter 90 |  | 1-0 |  | Pickering Town | Att: 115 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Tue 4/10/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town |  | 0-4 |  | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 20, 81 Curtis Bernard 67 Bill Law 90 | Att: 564 HT: 0-1 |
| L | Sat 8/10/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town Lee Pallender 28 |  | 1-2 |  | Parkgate Christopher Wood 15pen Ashley Worsfold 77 | Att: 90 HT: 1-1 |
| D | Tue 11/10/2011 | NCELP | Retford United Darren Blandon 8og Carl Haslam 16 Robert Austin 47 |  | 3-3 |  | Pickering Town Joel Ramm 11 Darren Blandon 45 Edward Cass 68 | Att: 158 HT: 2-2 |
| L | Sat 15/10/2011 | NCELP | Tadcaster Albion Graeme Whitehead 26 Carl Stewart 37 |  | 2-1 |  | Pickering Town Richard Batley 63 | Att: 168 HT: 2-0 |
| L | Sat 22/10/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town Stuart Rice 48 |  | 1-2 |  | Staveley Miners Welfare Ryan Damms 24pen, 52 | Att: 127 HT: 0-1 |
| D | Sat 29/10/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town Chaz Wrigley 28 Richard Batley 42 Jonathan Brown 83 |  | 3-3 |  | Thackley Ben Hardy 25, 58 Nicky Matthews 50 | Att: 98 HT: 2-1 |
| November |
| L | Sat 5/11/2011 | NCELP | Bridlington Town James Bennett 55 David Hartas 70og Billy Logan 90 |  | 3-2 |  | Pickering Town Stuart Rice 16, 20 | Att: 185 HT: 0-2 |
| W | Tue 8/11/2011 | NRSC2 | Scarborough Town Martyn Ferrey 58 |  | 1-2 |  | Pickering Town David Hartas 33 Steve Hart 48 | Att: 223 HT: 0-1 |
| (at Pickering Town FC) |
| W | Sat 12/11/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town Stuart King 12og Joel Ramm 28 Jonathan Brown 55 Stuart Rice 72 Chaz Wrigley 86 |  | 5-0 |  | Lincoln Moorlands Railway | Att: 113 HT: 2-0 |
| W | Sat 19/11/2011 | NCELP | Lincoln Moorlands Railway Luke Forbes 47 |  | 1-2 |  | Pickering Town Jonathan Birbeck 63 Joel Ramm 75 | Att: 73 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Sat 26/11/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town Marc Thompson 18 |  | 1-5 |  | Brighouse Town Anthony Haigh 10, 40 Tom Matthews 62, 80 Nick Jagger 66 | Att: 142 HT: 1-2 |
| December |
| L | Sat 3/12/2011 | NCELP | Winterton Rangers Gavin Cooper 52 Jack Cross 57 |  | 2-0 |  | Pickering Town | Att: 112 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Tue 6/12/2011 | LC2 | Pickering Town Luke Ibbetson 4, 8, 18, 49 Jamie Fradgley 33og |  | 5-0 |  | Brighouse Town | Att: 97 HT: 4-0 |
| (Pickering Town removed from competition for fielding ineligible player - Brighouse Town reinstated) |
| L | Sat 10/12/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town |  | 0-1 |  | Maltby Main Ben Langford 63 | Att: 115 HT: 0-0 |
| D | Sat 17/12/2011 | NCELP | Maltby Main Ben Langford 32 |  | 1-1 |  | Pickering Town Tom Adams 87 | Att: 72 HT: 1-0 |
| W | Mon 26/12/2011 | NCELP | Pickering Town Michael McNaughton 10 Jonathan Brown 23 Tom Reid 43 |  | 3-0 |  | Selby Town | Att: 180 HT: 3-0 |
| January |
| W | Mon 2/1/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Steve Baxter 20 Liam Salt 21, 63 Tom Adams 45pen Simon Sturdy 68 |  | 5-2 |  | Hall Road Rangers Michael Gawthorpe 32, 75 | Att: 180 HT: 3-1 |
| W | Tue 10/1/2012 | Frdly | Pickering Town Steve Baxter 10 Joel Ramm 70 |  | 2-1 |  | Dunnington Tom Richards 80 | HT: 1-0 |
| L | Sat 14/1/2012 | NCELP | Scarborough Athletic Ryan Blott 4, 74pen Adam Lee 35 |  | 3-1 |  | Pickering Town David Hartas 6 | Att: 508 HT: 2-1 |
| D | Sat 21/1/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Darren Clough 88 |  | 1-1 |  | Retford United Adam Scott 52 | Att: 141 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Tue 24/1/2012 | NRSCQF | Grangetown Boys Club Mick Drury 12 Lewis Simms 42 Josh Keogh 44 Lee Seeds 90 |  | 4-2 |  | Pickering Town Simon Sturdy 45 Steve Baxter 86 | Att: 71 HT: 3-1 |
| (at Thornaby FC) |
| W | Sat 28/1/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Steve Baxter 21, 48 Simon Sturdy 42 Jonathan Brown 59 Tom Adams 71 |  | 5-0 |  | Nostell Miners Welfare | Att: 146 HT: 2-0 |
| February |
| W | Sat 18/2/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Tom Adams 3pen Joel Ramm 43 |  | 2-1 |  | Barton Town Old Boys Ryan Cooper 13 | Att: 144 HT: 2-1 |
| L | Sat 25/2/2012 | NCELP | Parkgate Janni Lipka 2, 41 Brian Cusworth 29, 49 Luke Fletcher 45 Ashley Worsfold 90pen |  | 6-1 |  | Pickering Town Tom Adams 13pen | Att: 107 HT: 4-1 |
| March |
| D | Sat 3/3/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Tom Fenwick 47 |  | 1-1 |  | Tadcaster Albion Tom Corner 66 | Att: 164 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Tue 6/3/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Tom Fenwick 10 Steve Baxter 86, 89 Lyle Hillier 88 |  | 4-1 |  | Armthorpe Welfare Joe Lumsden 90 | Att: 124 HT: 1-0 |
| W | Sat 10/3/2012 | NCELP | Long Eaton United Blaine Hancock 88 |  | 1-3 |  | Pickering Town Carl Stewart 58, 67 Russell Parker 83 | Att: 84 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Sat 17/3/2012 | NCELP | Thackley James Firth 47 Chris Davey 56 Adam Mitchell 88og |  | 3-2 |  | Pickering Town Darren Clough 69, 90 | Att: 112 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Sat 24/3/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Carl Stewart 10, 24, 64 |  | 3-1 |  | Bridlington Town Nathan Cook 80 | Att: 247 HT: 2-0 |
| W | Sat 31/3/2012 | NCELP | Liversedge Alex Hallam 7 |  | 1-3 |  | Pickering Town Tom Fenwick 28 Carl Stewart 48, 65 | Att: 118 HT: 1-1 |
| April |
| W | Sat 7/4/2012 | NCELP | Staveley Miners Welfare |  | 0-1 |  | Pickering Town Russell Parker 73 | Att: 270 HT: 0-0 |
| W | Mon 9/4/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Tom Fenwick 56 Carl Stewart 90 |  | 2-0 |  | Long Eaton United | Att: 194 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Sat 14/4/2012 | NCELP | Brighouse Town Tom Matthews 18, 64, 87 Daniel Hull 27 |  | 4-2 |  | Pickering Town Steve Baxter 10, 40 | Att: 76 HT: 2-2 |
| W | Sat 21/4/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Ged Dalton 35 Joe Connor 87 |  | 2-1 |  | Winterton Rangers Scott Bibby 82 | Att: 218 HT: 1-0 |
| W | Tue 24/4/2012 | NCELP | Pickering Town Josh Handley 48og Jonathan Brown 78 |  | 2-0 |  | Arnold Town | Att: 130 HT: 0-0 |
| L | Sat 28/4/2012 | NCELP | Armthorpe Welfare Paul Ashton 45 David Buck 70 Henry Sibenge 83 |  | 3-1 |  | Pickering Town Carl Stewart 63 | Att: 72 HT: 1-0 |