| NCEL President's Cup First Round | 
									
										|  | 9/8/20119/8 | Barton Town Old Boys Barton TownGareth Barlow 38, 70
 | 2-1 Att: 90
 HT: 1-0
 | Glasshoughton Welfare Glasshoughton WelfCarl Fothergill 88pen
 | 
									
										|  | 10/8/20119/8 | Handsworth Handsworth [1]Brian Cusworth 43
 | 1-0 Att: 101
 HT: 1-0
 | AFC Emley Emley AFC
 | 
									
										|  | 10/8/201110/8 | Lincoln Moorlands Railway Lincoln Moorlands RailwayTom Garrick 12, 107, 110, 112
 | 4-1 (aet)
 Att: 62
 HT: 1-0
 90: 1-1
 | Louth Town Louth TownDanny Stevens 87
 | 
									
										|  | 13/9/201110/8 | Pickering Town Pickering TownKingsley Wetherald 67
 Lewis Taylor 90
 | 2-3 Att: 125
 HT: 0-3
 | Bridlington Town Bridlington TownCraig Hogg 31
 Josh Greening 37, 40
 | 
									
										|  | 9/8/201110/8 | Pontefract Collieries Pontefract CollieriesGreig McGrory 33
 | 1-0 Att: 63
 HT: 1-0
 | Nostell Miners Welfare Nostell MW
 | 
									
										|  | 10/8/201110/8 | Staveley Miners Welfare Staveley Miners WelfareJoseph Thornton 70
 Ryan Damms 84
 | 2-1 Att: 102
 HT: 0-1
 | Thackley ThackleyDean Walters 2
 | 
									
										|  | 10/8/201110/8 | Tadcaster Albion Tadcaster AlbionGraeme Whitehead 13, 42
 Thomas Reid 23pen
 Ryan Qualter 52
 Carl Stewart 56
 Matthew Howgate 90
 | 6-0 Att: 54
 HT: 3-0
 | Yorkshire Amateur Yorkshire Amateur
 | 
									
										|  | 10/8/201113/9 | Winterton Rangers Winterton RangersDaniel Barlow 15, 108
 Joe Leesley 24
 Aaron Moxam 112
 | 4-2 (aet)
 Att: 67
 HT: 2-2
 90: 2-2
 | Parkgate ParkgateJordan Turner 10, 27
 | 
||||||
| NCEL President's Cup Second Round | 
									
										|  | 29/11/201116/11 | Barton Town Old Boys Barton TownScott Phillips 12, 32
 Ashley Lattimore 16
 | 3-1 Att: 74
 HT: 3-0
 | Bridlington Town Bridlington TownFrancis Belt 76
 | 
									
										|  | 30/11/201129/11 | Handsworth Handsworth [1]
 | 0-1 Att: 47
 HT: 0-1
 | Pontefract Collieries Pontefract CollieriesJames McDaid 27
 | 
						
							| (Pontefract Collieries removed from competition for fielding ineligible player - Handsworth reinstated) | 
									
										|  | 14/12/201130/11 | Tadcaster Albion Tadcaster AlbionDaniel Gray 22, 27
 Robert Pell 51
 Carl Stewart 89
 | 4-3 Att: 54
 HT: 2-2
 | Staveley Miners Welfare Staveley Miners WelfareJoseph Thornton 11, 40
 Jordan Eagers 52
 | 
									
										|  | 16/11/201114/12 | Winterton Rangers Winterton RangersLiam Wilkin 52
 | 1-0 Att: 66
 HT: 0-0
 | Lincoln Moorlands Railway Lincoln Moorlands Railway
 | 
||||||
| NCEL President's Cup Semi-Finals | 
									
										|  | 31/1/201218/1 | Barton Town Old Boys Barton TownRichard Medcalf 4
 | 1-0 Att: 62
 HT: 1-0
 | Tadcaster Albion Tadcaster Albion
 | 
									
										|  | 18/1/201231/1 | Handsworth Handsworth [1]Richard Tootle 85, 87
 | 2-1 Att: 90
 HT: 0-0
 | Winterton Rangers Winterton RangersGavin Cooper 53
 | 
||||||
| NCEL President's Cup Final | 
									
										|  | 2/5/20122/5 | Barton Town Old Boys Barton TownAshley Lattimore 30
 Matthew Plant 79
 Ryan Cooper 90
 | 3-4 (aet)
 Att: 240
 HT: 1-0
 90: 3-3
 | Handsworth Handsworth [1]Sam Smith 61pen, 84, 99pen
 Luke Broadbent 88
 | 
						
							| (at Winterton Rangers FC) |