| August | |||||||
| Sat 19/8/1995 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 1-1 | | Pontefract Collieries | |
| Sat 26/8/1995 | FACP | Yorkshire Amateur | | 2-4 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| September | |||||||
| Sat 2/9/1995 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 2-0 | | Parkgate | |
| Sat 9/9/1995 | FAC1Q | Winsford United | | 1-0 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Wed 13/9/1995 | NCEL1 | Worsbrough Bridge Athletic | | 1-1 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 16/9/1995 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 1-1 | | Selby Town | |
| Sat 30/9/1995 | FAV2Q | Borrowash Victoria | | 1-4 | | Cheadle Town | |
| October | |||||||
| Sat 7/10/1995 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 2-0 | | Blidworth Welfare | |
| Sat 14/10/1995 | NCEL1 | Winterton Rangers | | 2-1 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Tue 17/10/1995 | WST2 | Louth United | | 3-0 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 21/10/1995 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 0-0 | | Yorkshire Amateur | |
| Tue 24/10/1995 | PC2 | Parkgate | | 0-7 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 28/10/1995 | NCEL1 | Louth United | | 3-2 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| November | |||||||
| Sat 4/11/1995 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 4-2 | | Brodsworth Welfare | |
| Sat 11/11/1995 | NCEL1 | Harrogate Railway | | 2-1 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Tue 14/11/1995 | PC3 | Belper Town | | 2-1 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 18/11/1995 | NCEL1 | Rossington Main | | 1-3 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 25/11/1995 | NCEL1 | Hall Road Rangers | | 1-2 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Tue 28/11/1995 | LC2 | Ossett Town | | 2-2 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| December | |||||||
| Sat 2/12/1995 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 3-6 | | Eccleshill United | |
| Sat 9/12/1995 | NCEL1 | Tadcaster Albion | | 1-4 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Tue 12/12/1995 | LC2R | Borrowash Victoria | | 1-0 | | Ossett Town | |
| Sat 16/12/1995 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 0-0 | | Garforth Town | |
| Wed 20/12/1995 | LC3 | Sutton Town | | 0-0 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 23/12/1995 | NCEL1 | Pontefract Collieries | | 3-2 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| January | |||||||
| Wed 3/1/1996 | LC3R | Borrowash Victoria | | 2-5 | | Sutton Town | |
| Sat 6/1/1996 | NCEL1 | Parkgate | | 2-6 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 13/1/1996 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 0-1 | | Rossington Main | |
| Tue 16/1/1996 | DSC3 | Borrowash Victoria | | 0-1 | | Graham Street Prims | |
| Sat 20/1/1996 | NCEL1 | Selby Town | | 2-1 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| February | |||||||
| Sat 3/2/1996 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 2-1 | | Worsbrough Bridge Athletic | |
| Sat 10/2/1996 | NCEL1 | Blidworth Welfare | | 1-3 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 17/2/1996 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 4-1 | | Louth United | |
| Sat 24/2/1996 | NCEL1 | Yorkshire Amateur | | 0-1 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| March | |||||||
| Sat 9/3/1996 | NCEL1 | Brodsworth Welfare | | 0-2 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 16/3/1996 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 8-1 | | Tadcaster Albion | |
| Sat 30/3/1996 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 0-1 | | Hall Road Rangers | |
| April | |||||||
| Sat 6/4/1996 | NCEL1 | Eccleshill United | | 1-0 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 13/4/1996 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 2-5 | | Harrogate Railway | |
| Sat 20/4/1996 | NCEL1 | Garforth Town | | 4-0 | | Borrowash Victoria | |
| Sat 27/4/1996 | NCEL1 | Borrowash Victoria | | 1-2 | | Winterton Rangers | |